Scenarios: Deficit panel talks loom for Medicare, Medicaid

August 17, 2011 | In: ARRA, CCHIT, EMR Stimulus Package, health IT, Health IT Policy

WASHINGTON (Reuters) – The government’s soaring healthcare bill will be high on the agenda of Congress’s new deficit-cutting “super committee,” which has been assigned the task of finding by November 23 at least $1.2 trillion in savings.

Few major structural changes are expected for the Medicare and Medicaid health insurance programs given the time constraints.

The 12 committee members — six Democrats and six Republicans — also are unlikely to seek more than small-scale changes in spending, if any at all, to the initiatives created under the 2010 healthcare law signed by President Barack Obama, one of his key legislative achievements.

The committee, formed this month under the last-minute debt-ceiling compromise between Obama and Congress, is far more likely to seek narrower but tangible results, according to analysts, former policymakers and congressional aides.

Committee members have said they expect to work from existing proposals from independent groups, Republican and Democratic lawmakers, Obama’s 2010 bipartisan deficit commission and others.

Here are some scenarios of how events might unfold.

IF THERE’S NO DEAL

The partisan mood in Congress could make it difficult for the committee to reach any agreement on a deficit-cutting package, or for Congress to approve a deal. Much may depend on how tough a line the White House urges Democrats to take on entitlements if Republicans refuse to include revenue increases.

Automatic cuts that will kick in if there is no agreement would not touch Medicaid, the $427 billion a year health insurance program for the poor that is funded jointly by federal and state governments and serves about 60 million beneficiaries.

Medicare, the $520 billion a year federal health insurance program for the elderly, would see a relatively modest $120 billion cutback over 10 years under automatic reductions.

Analysts say the Medicare cuts would impact healthcare providers, not the program’s 48 million beneficiaries. That could help avoid a backlash from elderly voters who might otherwise seek retribution at the ballot box for any reductions in Medicare benefits.

But the provider cuts, amounting to no more than 2 percent of total Medicare spending, would have a direct impact on the bottom lines of companies like UnitedHealth Group and Humana Inc that depend on Medicare spending for revenues. The prospect for reductions has already unsettled stocks on Wall Street.

IF THERE IS A DEAL

Speculation about the committee’s ability to reach agreement centers on whether any lawmakers would be willing to break party lines.

Some analysts believe Democratic Senator Patty Murray could cross party lines to help Republicans stave off cuts in defense spending, a move that could mean deeper reductions in healthcare programs.

Murray represents Washington state, home to defense contractor Boeing Co, which has given her more than $172,000 in campaign contributions from corporate and employee donations, according to the independent nonpartisan Center for Responsive Politics.

But analysts also note Murray’s 2012 role as head of the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee helping to get Democrats elected to the Senate, which could constrain her from supporting changes to Medicare and Medicaid that might hurt her party’s prospects in the congressional and presidential elections.

Some conservatives hold out hope that Republicans on the super committee will move the debate in the direction of House of Representatives Budget Committee Chairman Paul Ryan’s proposals to convert Medicare into a premium-support program for purchasing private insurance and Medicaid into a block-grant system for states.

But committee members are more likely to make progress by avoiding the big ideological battles that are becoming set pieces for the 2012 campaign. Instead, the focus is expected to be on savings capable of winning approval from Congress and a favorable reception from the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office, which is expected to veto any panel recommendations.

Copyright © 2011, Reuters

digg Scenarios: Deficit panel talks loom for Medicare, Medicaid
reddit Scenarios: Deficit panel talks loom for Medicare, Medicaid
stumbleupon Scenarios: Deficit panel talks loom for Medicare, Medicaid
yahoo buzz Scenarios: Deficit panel talks loom for Medicare, Medicaid
dzone Scenarios: Deficit panel talks loom for Medicare, Medicaid
facebook Scenarios: Deficit panel talks loom for Medicare, Medicaid
delicious Scenarios: Deficit panel talks loom for Medicare, Medicaid
dotnetkicks Scenarios: Deficit panel talks loom for Medicare, Medicaid
dotnetshoutout Scenarios: Deficit panel talks loom for Medicare, Medicaid
linkedin Scenarios: Deficit panel talks loom for Medicare, Medicaid
technorati Scenarios: Deficit panel talks loom for Medicare, Medicaid
twitter Scenarios: Deficit panel talks loom for Medicare, Medicaid
google buzz Scenarios: Deficit panel talks loom for Medicare, Medicaid
Bookmark and Share

Are you interested in receiving e-Learning Courses for Healthcare, which maximize your business performance at reduced costs?
Join eLearning

Follow Us